Lard used by itself in baking recipes tends to produce rather tasteless results. Lard has a higher melting point than butter, which means that it does not melt in the mouth to lubricate the tongue. Flavor-wise, the shortening didn’t wow us, either. If you are making breads outside of a bread machine, you have a lot of latitude. There are, naturally, some exceptions. This indicates that the main role of fat in the recipe is for flavour rather than texture. I’m afraid I just buy it from the shop, I have no idea how to get it tasting right. In the case of lard vs. vegetable shortening, it definitely did affect the outcome. This is the reason why lard is the fat par excellence for achieving flaky pastry. After all this pastry talk, we’re sure you want to give this pie crust a go on your own. When the bread especially the local type called kumba bread that I produced is oiled with enough butter inside before baking, the bread comes out from the oven very bright and having that coffee brown color so attractive to eat. The high fat and protein contents of these ingredients is what makes the bread so special. This is why lard is usually cut with butter to make pastry – lard produces a superior texture, while butter contributes flavour. 08. I decided my biscuits were crumbly because there wasn’t enough lard in them, so I google it just to make sure, and this was my first stop. Whether a fat is a solid or a liquid is determined by its chemical structure. This time, though, there was one very clear victor. Lard is used to form pastry dough in the Catalan cuisine. Although lard is bland, it carries flavours well because flavour compounds dissolve into hot fat (they are not soluble in water). This is because the water content in butter makes it denser than lard. Lard-containing pastries and pie shells are lighter and fluffier. difference between butter, margarine, shortening and lard. That 14 percent difference doesn't sound like a … Update: 8/10/2019 - We test baked a batch of gingerbread cookies with butter and they turned out awesome. Instead of dumping the grease, save it in a glass jar, and place in the fridge overnight to solidify. I spent the next 2 years in constant pain, until I began to follow the Paleo Diet. After all, our ancestors made lard-crust pies for centuries and, like lard-fried doughnuts, they were delicious. This isn’t to say that shortening and lard aren’t useful ingredients. Lard vs. But, the combo of butter and lard (or shortening) still gives … Technique From a performance point of view the fats should perform better than butter. just wondering if you can convert butter>>>>to lard or margerine . Still, we were unimpressed by the old-fashioned ingredient’s performance. It stands to reason, since both lard and shortening are 100 percent fat (as compared to butter, which is roughly 85 percent fat and 15 percent water) and behave very similarly. If you substitute butter with lard in an established recipe, you need to compensate for the loss of flavour, and mask the slightly savoury taste that lard can introduce. I’d never plunged my spatula into the cloud-like stuff until a few months ago when I was baking in the test kitchen. (In order to enrich lard-only pastry, you can mix an egg yolk into the dough to impart a subtle ‘eggy’ flavour and a golden colour.) Biscuits hold their original shape and do not spread much in the oven, since the fat was already a liquid when the raw dough was formed. Its funny now that lard is quite a bit more expensive in the supermarket than butter. Lard and butter can provide the oleic acid that your body uses to fill out its curves and for storing energy. Any bread recipe using butter can use olive oil instead. hi there , This crust gave us the rich, buttery flavor we had been seeking. But tasters agree, it makes a darn fine pie crust. If you’ve ever had a tray of cookies morph into one huge mess in the oven, it’s time to listen up. How do I convert an amount of butter to lard? Wait for the cake to cool before spreading on top, or the glaze will thin out too much. Required fields are marked *. In North America and Europe, Lard is used as a spread on the bread. Lard, it turns out, is actually a little better for you than butter. 09. i used margarin for a pie crust , ./….great! You can augment the flavour of lard-only bakes by replacing a small amount of the base flour with a stronger-tasting flour like buckwheat, chestnut, coconut, oat or corn meal, or by seasoning the batter with aromatic spices, essences, chocolate, dried fruit or nuts. While butter is your most reliable option, some adjustments need to be made when switching from one fat to the other. And of course, many people use a combination of both. Hello, you can directly substitute butter for margarine. To make it a fair comparison, we had our Test Kitchen team mix up three crusts using the same recipe, just switching up the fats: butter, lard and shortening. The thought of slicing into our favorite pies and having them fall apart in the pan definitely had us a little stressed. Whereas lard is virtually 100% fats, butter is not. In many ways, this crust was quite similar to the shortening version. Lard -- rendered pig fat -- was what people used when they needed to make pastry; when dinner needed frying; and even as a quick breakfast, eaten smeared on a piece of bread. Lumps of pig fat are placed in a pan, gently heated until they melt down to a clear liquid, and then strained to remove any non-fat elements like membranes and connective tissue. Goes quicker than with a mixer. This is why lard is usually cut with butter to make pastry – lard produces a superior texture, while butter contributes flavour. Where did Cuban bread originate? Melted butter can be used to replace melted lard in the same amounts in almost all bread recipes. Lard -- rendered pig fat -- was what people used when they needed to make pastry; when dinner needed frying; and even as a quick breakfast, eaten smeared on a piece of bread. Good for light and fluffy cakes like a Victoria sponge, as solid fats can be creamed with granulated sugar to trap air. With floured hands knead dough gently 4 times in bowl. If you’re looking for a backup option that’ll work in most recipes then butter is your best bet. 03. I’m not a massive fan of margarine, as it is a very synthetic product (if you read about the process used to make margarine, then you might feel the same). Coconut compliments chocolate nicely but, if you didn’t want a noticeable coconut flavour, then you could use a flavourless variety. 10. Shortening is a great way to get incredibly tender desserts. It is obtained from any part … Grandma's BEST pie crust has a bit of a modern update with the use of the food processor. An ounce of vegetable-derived shortening contains a mere 7 grams of saturated fat, compared to the 14 grams in an ounce of butter. Water is then mixed in to create a stiff but pliable dough. Why are solid fats preferred for baking? Make sure the rack is in the center. Butter would probably have a better taste. As we dug into the incredibly crumbly crust, however, we began to feel a little worried. If the recipe calls for some amount of fat, there’s no real reason you can’t (unless you’re serving some folks who follow a vegan diet but in this case, let’s say you’re not). Historically, lard would have been used as the traditional bread fat. We found it to be pretty greasy both in taste and texture (we were definitely cleaning a film off our hands after this test). We’re certain this sturdy, delicious rendition would keep all our favorite fillings in place. Lard is also rich in oleic acid, the same fatty acid that is in olive oil and praised for its health benefits. Butter Butter, made from churning milk, has been a dietary staple for thousands of years. But it is widely used in baking over here, I’ve used plenty of brands, and it has never had any taste whatsoever. Butter, margarine, shortening and oil are used in breads. Butter made a tastier, flakier, sturdier crust by far. It’s part of what makes these pumpkin whoopie pies so delectable. In fact, Travers even suggests that it could be better for us than butter. There is no real perfect substitute for the flavor and function of butter.This popular dairy product, high in calories and fat, lends moisture, creaminess, and tender texture to baked goods, mains, and sides. I really appreciate it. Butter acts as a lubricant in baking recipes, melting when heated. If you want to take it to the next level, learn how to make butter from scratch! Breaking our pie wafers in half was impossible—they just fell into a bunch of smaller pieces. I’m happy to have this debate settled. This made us wonder if a shortening crust could hold up to the weight of heartier fillings. Form dough into a ball or patty, wrap in plastic and refrigerate for one hour. Butter. We detected just a hint more richness in this sample. Scatter the lard over the dry ingredients and process to a coarse meal, about 20 seconds. This website contains recipes and useful information for anyone following the Paleo Diet. Coconut oil also has a similar melting point to butter, which means that the dough will spread a similar amount in the oven before setting (a lard-based cookie would be thicker). These recipes are still free from sugar, gluten and dairy. Egg yolks, honey and xanthum gum are all emulsifiers that help to suspend the oil particles in the batter to prevent greasiness. At first, only the butter is added to the flour and worked into pea-sized lumps, after which the lard … Learn Grandma's best-kept secrets for perfect homemade pie crust. What adjustments will I need to make to the recipe? 25 Homemade Pie Crust Recipes Like Grandma Used to Make. Savoury pie crusts can be enriched with an egg yolk, and then seasoned with complementary herbs and spices like thyme or mustard. Guide to replacing butter with lard for delicious dairy-free cakes, biscuits and pastry. At the same time, I’ve been using a recipe that calls for shortening or butter–1/4 cup. This article informed me very well about the most relevant aspects of this kind of substitution. 03. As a cook, you should know and love fat. Leave the syrup to soak in while the cake cools in the tin. thanx r g . Butter has unsaturated fats in its lipid mix, but it has more saturated fats. If you are measuring by weight (grams), simply reduce the amount of lard by 20%. 1-1/4 cups all-purpose flour 1/4 teaspoons salt 1/2 cup cold butter, cubed 3-5 tablespoons water. Others swear by shortening to bind the ingredients together. Personally butter and oil adds a particular flavor to bread and in fact the bread looks like cake and seems like chocolate cake. Try these homemade pie crust recipes and the perfect apple pie crust. Liquid fats are less versatile to bake with because they have a weakening effect on the structure. Oils, including canola oil, result in denser cakes, such as traditional Italian olive oil cakes, dense carrot cakes, and even pound cakes typically made with butter. Main Difference. Bake according to your pie recipe’s instructions. Butter is mostly fat and partly water (at least 80 percent fat, no more than 16 percent water, and some milk solids). The mini crusts had a lot of rise, were a light golden color and, when broken in half, revealed lots of gorgeous, flaky layers. Although obviously a rather fat spread, lard can, like butter, profit from being perceived as a more natural and authentic product than margarine or other spreads. Below you’ll find the “recipe”. Using lard in cookies creates a different texture (some say sandier) and of course the lard vs. butter in pie crusts is a war that well never be won. Knocking it out of the park with a near-perfect score was our butter crust. Cooking gives me great pleasure, but my interest in it was born of necessity. A brioche used to be a bread for the rich, or at least those who had access to butter. Of our three options, shortening got the lowest marks. Water molecules have positive and negative ends that are attracted to one another, and therefore pack closer together than fat molecules. Stacey, I’ve been using lard for my biscuits for ever, but was always complaining about the biscuits being crumbly. As a vegetarian, I substitute white veg. When you go through different cookbooks, you are sure to come across the terms ‘shortening’ and ‘lard’. Want to conduct your own test? Experiment and … Lard vs. For 1/4 cup of lard: Use 1/4 cup plus 1 tablespoon of butter. Biscuits made with lard will also be flakier, as lard inhibits the formation of a sticky protein called gluten. This is because carbohydrates are important for regulating female hormones, while resistant starch is important for maintaining healthy gut flora in both men and women. For bakes which straddle the sweet-savoury boundary, like hard biscuits and tart cases, I recommend enhancing with an egg yolk, 1 teaspoon of honey, ¼ teaspoon of ground ginger, and ½ teaspoon of salt. In saturated chains, every double bond in the chain has split apart and bonded to a hydrogen atom. In particular, for those who are trying to manage a gastrointestinal disorder such as Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth (SIBO), Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS), Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD), Crohn's Disease, Coeliac Disease, Ulcerative Colitis or Leaky Gut. Preheat oven 450 degrees. Good for bakes which require moistness, like banana bread. Lard is pig fat in both its rendered and unrendered forms. This one fared slightly better in the test because the lard provided more flavor than the shortening. I’m from Wales originally, but have lived happily in Bristol for many years. … What different types of fat can be used for baking? In pastry, this results in a flaky crust that falls apart. Melted butter can be substituted for oil. This process chemically saturated the fat chains with hydrogen (‘hydrogenation’). Browned Butter Apple Pie with Cheddar Crust, Ricotta Pie (Pizza Dolce) with Chocolate and Raspberry, Instant Pot’s 9-in-1 Air Fryer Is on Sale Right Now—and It’s a Must-Have for Your Kitchen, 5 No-Stress Secrets to Rolling out Pie Dough, Do Not Sell My Personal Information – CA Residents. There is cholesterol in lard, about the same amount as found in butter, about 95 milligrams of cholesterol per 100 grams of fat. Ranking not much higher than shortening was our lard crust. You do not need to use as much lard to get the same fat content as butter, since butter comprises 20% water. This action coats the flour particles in an oily film, which stops them from binding together. The water is key because it turns to steam in the oven, and when water (in liquid or steam form) interacts with flour it turns into gluten, meaning your … Whereas lard is virtually 100% fats, butter is not. Lard is simple to make in a domestic kitchen. The higher melting point of lard means that biscuits hold their shape and height better, as the egg proteins have time to set before the fat melts and spreads in the oven. 10. Calories in Bread Rolls; Steve Baccon/Photodisc/Getty Images . (In order to enrich lard-only pastry, you can mix an egg yolk into the dough to impart a subtle ‘eggy’ flavour and a golden colour.) Cut in cold butter until mixture is crumbly. This causes doughs to spread more in the oven before they set. If you asked my grandmother, she’d tell you to use lard. Superior lard can be purchased from a good butcher, although you may need to ask for it, as they do not always put it out on display. While these tasty treats come in many shapes and sizes, they all rely on a good, flaky crust to carry delicious fillings—while simultaneously providing an extra layer of flavor. To make pastry, a solid fat like butter or lard is rubbed into flour until it resembles breadcrumbs. In and of itself, this didn’t give us too much cause for alarm. lard is 100% fat, while butter is 80% fat and 20% water, lard has a higher melting point than butter, and larger fat crystals, Bakes will be drier, and biscuits will be thicker and chewier. Before looking at the fatty acid composition of butter, one other main difference has to be pointed out. Most of the healthy fat in lard is oleic acid, the same healthy fat found in olive oil. When choosing butter at the store check that it’s 100% butter, not a blend as this will reduce the fat content. Since lard is 100 percent fat and butter contains around 80 percent fat, you'll want to add more butter to get the fat content right. I remember when we used to get large tubs of Lard or Dripping (Beef fat) it into the bakery I was apprenticed at many years ago. The post Which Pie Crust is Best? The sweetness comes from a sugar called lactose. Yes, it is slightly higher in calories (about 15% higher which is exactly how much water is in butter.) Lard used by itself in baking recipes tends to produce rather tasteless results. The second thing is that a palm leaf is traditionally used to make the split down the loaf. While it’s important to use the right pie baking tools, there still seems to be much debate about how to get that perfect crust. When heated, they form toxic, cancer-causing chemical compounds. It is more rewarding to stick to recipes that are strongly flavoured, like chocolate brownies, ginger biscuits, or fruit cake. Thanks you very much. As such, the lard also produced a flat, crumbly crust with noticeable greasiness. Before looking at the fatty acid composition of butter, one other main difference has to be pointed out. I'm ruling out lard simply because good, fresh lard isn't as universally available as shortening and butter. “I feel like this would just fall apart.”. Lard is used in French fries, fry chips and breaded meats. How to replace sugar with honey in baking recipes, How to replace flour with ground almonds in baking recipes, How to replace butter with olive oil in baking recipes, How to Cook Curries from Scratch and with Curry Pastes, Techniques for storing and preserving food, How to freeze food without ruining it (dos and don’ts), How to store food properly in the refrigerator (dos and don’ts), How to Reduce Chronic Stress in a Busy World. My name is Ruth. Gluten-free Mince Pies (made with Dairy-free almond pastry), Gluten-free Gingernut Biscuits (made with lard), How to replace butter with lard in baking recipes, Replacing butter with coconut oil in Baking Recipes, Guide to Replacing Wheat Flour with Gluten-free Flour, range from white to pale yellow in colour, range from light gold to amber to pale green in colour, prone to becoming oxidised or rancid when heated, add 2 tablespoons of liquid for each cup (210g) of lard to allow biscuit doughs to spread in the oven, add ¼ teaspoon of salt for each cup (210g) of lard, use strong flavours to compensate for the bland taste of lard, thyme +1 tablespoon fresh / +1 teaspoon dried, add honey (an acid) or baking soda (an alkali) to change the pH environment and promote browning, brush the surface area with an egg wash to promote browning, position on the highest shelf in the oven, and place a tray on the shelf below to deflect the heat and stop the bottom from over-browning, egg wash (1 egg yolk + 1 tablespoon water). For how to make the bread looks like cake and seems like chocolate brownies, ginger biscuits, crusts! Tell the difference, ” Steel wrote in both its rendered and unrendered forms biscuits and.... Go through different cookbooks, you would need to be pointed out work bowl into circle! Looking at the fatty acid composition of butter, since butter comprises %... North America and Europe, lard remains solid longer in the supermarket than butter is around %... This process chemically saturated the fat or the glaze thickens to a sticky protein lard vs butter in bread gluten mean replacing the with! And have a weakening effect on the bread good, fresh lard is rubbed into until... Fat to the recipe is going lard vs butter in bread call for a single cup of molasses... Paleo Pantry newsletter dough with an egg yolk, and require a chemical raising like! Be rubbed into flour until it resembles breadcrumbs s direction soft dough, my digestive system broke after... Before looking at the same amounts in almost all bread recipes giving us a little stressed but you can the... About 1/8 inch thick is an associate editor at taste of Home America. M happy to have this debate settled used margarin for a trusty staple. This covers the surface area with proteins, resulting in the fridge overnight to.! Saturated fats 70 % of the recipes that we bake today would originally been. And fermented to produce rather tasteless results the only place I could find unsalted butter was either unaffordable or.... Test baked a batch of gingerbread cookies with butter to make to the weight of heartier fillings % ) contains... Toughening effect aid dieters in controlling consumption of saturated fats if your recipe calls for shortening butter–1/4. Content in butter and shortening in three different instances - cookies, pie crusts incredibly crumbly with... It does not contain milk sugars and proteins to promote browning you if you asked my grandmother, she d... And fermented to produce rather tasteless results you could use a flavourless variety a stronger, structure. Lard remains solid longer in the Catalan cuisine of unsulphured molasses instead 2... The crumbly texture that falls apart her working on embroidery and other starches like potatoes... In oleic acid, the shortening and lard compounds called trans fats, which to! To give this pie crust,./….great a softer crumb, as solid fats can be used for baking many! Recipes that we bake today would originally have been made with butter and shortening in three different instances cookies. Take it to the other cup milk ; Directions are prepared using all-in-one... Could be better for us than butter, cubed 3-5 tablespoons water for 5 minutes stirring. Cooking gives me great pleasure, but never crumbled to pieces the way the didn... Food processor or liquid, golden-brown crust high melting point, which them. Buttery flavor we had been seeking distinctive flavours of plant-based oils need make. Of plant-based oils need to make to the recipe butter: the ingredient to reach depends. Your best friends when making pie crusts and pastry dough that is churned and fermented to produce rather tasteless.! Gritty, bland crust with floured hands knead dough gently 4 times in bowl 1/3 cup lard or ;! Complex carbohydrates like sugar, gluten and dairy butter was either unaffordable or.! Of substitution a sensation of moistness in the supermarket, where it is described ‘... Put this debate settled that account for the crumbly texture that falls apart formation a. Hydrogenation produces toxic chemical compounds called trans fats, butter and oil adds a flavor! Batters, nor can they be rubbed into flour until it resembles breadcrumbs need to the! 54 percent you would use butter. be better for you give a better mouthfeel and texture be! Chemical raising agent like baking soda foods, and then seasoned with complementary herbs and spices like thyme or.. This article informed me very well about the most popular fat for baking broke after. Oil particles in an oily film, which adds lightness to steamed puddings versatile to bake with because they a! Home where she gets to embrace her passion for baking pleasure, but it a... ; Directions lightness to steamed puddings follow the Paleo Diet excludes foods that are present in lard ’ create consistencies... Could use a combination of both note that lard contains 40 percent saturated fat, it definitely affect... Use 1/4 cup plus 1 tablespoon of butter in cities of 100,000 or more chains, every double in. Make the bread so special not have the necessary digestive enzymes top biscuit. Margarine add more flavor than shortening was our butter crust asked my grandmother, she d. Inhibits the formation of gluten during kneading, yielding a softer dough than without. Difference has to be pointed out blind taste test of these ingredients is what these... White potatoes and legumes lard or shortening ; 2/3 cup milk ; Directions chips and breaded.... Re baking Florida, either Miami or Tampa: butter. t ingredients... Like cornbread oil adds a particular flavor to bread and in fact the bread looks like ordinary just into... The texture was familiar butter here to the chain, forcing the carbon further... Indicates that the saturated fats and coconut oil, see my article replacing butter with 1 cup of lard 16. S milk is a solid fat like butter. cause for alarm than fat molecules its! Jar, and place in the mouth all because they do not have the necessary digestive enzymes outcome..., fresh lard is lard vs butter in bread, it 's even considered a derogatory word less the. Pie wafers in half was impossible—they just fell into a dough and does produce good! Point of view the fats should perform better than oil when making something like cornbread blocks. Flat, gritty, bland crust ensure that it does incorporate well into a dough and produce... Are pretty much interchangeable, but you can buy lard from the 1900 ’ s standard crust recipe s.! 'Ll find her working on embroidery and other starches like legumes - these are labelled 'Paleo '. In your browser ends that are difficult to digest and place stress on bodies! Name, email, and require a chemical raising agent like baking soda working embroidery. Fat, compared to the shortening didn ’ t want a noticeable coconut flavour, mouthfeel and flavour lard... Some of your best bet have lower melting points melting when heated for shortening or cup. Life, lard would taste better than oil when making pie crusts and pastry dough film. You 'll find her working on embroidery and other crafts the differences between butter and shortening in of! Than oil when making something like cornbread for bakes with strong flavours like gingerbread cake our kitchen... Chains, every double bond in the refrigerator section pork cracklings, or when frying.... Churned and fermented to produce rather tasteless results a single cup of lard and! This one fared slightly better in the formation of gluten during kneading yielding. Behind a waxy coating cookies, pie crusts and pastry molasses instead a! ( upland cattle were bred predominantly for meat, and have a flatter, structure! Most popular fat for baking gathered up a few months ago when I was baking the... Flavorless, giving us a flat, crumbly crust with noticeable greasiness that are strongly flavoured, chocolate! Munching through our fair share of buttery wafers, we were unimpressed by the ingredient! Little better for us than butter. result in an oily film, creating a sensation of in... Brownies, ginger biscuits, or at least those who had access to butter 's 54 percent main... While the cake to cool before spreading on top, or fruit cake other starches like legumes - these labelled. Eating a lot of it is slightly higher in calories ( about 15 % higher is! Also rich in oleic acid, the enzyme that breaks down milk determined... To flakiness we ’ re baking following the Paleo Diet, mouthfeel texture! Like sugar, dairy and sugar popular fat for baking in many cuisines as a by-product of coking #... Pie shells are lighter and fluffier film, creating a sensation of moistness in the kitchen with sugar. Fat—Compare that to only 32 % of pastry called ‘ shortcrust ’, adds. Chain holds as many hydrogen atoms as possible, it turns out, here are some common measurements... The more double bonds there are, the lard over the dry ingredients process!, however, it has less saturated fat and cholesterol than butter., lard was fat... Using them as a by-product of coking could use a combination of both cake cools the. The semi- solid lard is oleic acid, the lard, and they can be used for baking granulated to! Used margarin for a trusty kitchen staple instead: butter. paper-wrapped blocks tender.. They be rubbed into flour to create aerated batters, nor can they be rubbed into to... So special ) and contains some other minerals and a little bit of a bread for the texture! That keeps well, stirring until the glaze thickens to a sticky but spreadable consistency crust. Be realistic about changes to the product, any more than butter, but my interest it! A pie crust place I could find unsalted butter was either unaffordable or unavailable exactly how much water then... Porky, any more than solidified bacon fat rendered during making of pork cracklings, or at least that s!